← AI LabInstruction Following · intermediate
Instruction Following: Constraint Compliance
Membandingkan dua respons yang sama-sama fasih tetapi hanya satu memenuhi seluruh constraint.
01 · Prompt
Write a 120–150 word explanation for a 13-year-old. Use exactly three bullet points, include one analogy, avoid jargon, and end with one question.
02A · Response A
A response that is clear and friendly, but uses four bullets and does not end with a question.
02B · Response B
A response that stays within the requested length, uses exactly three bullets, contains a simple analogy, avoids jargon, and ends with a question.
03 · Rubric
- Constraint compliance — 40%
- Age-appropriate clarity — 25%
- Accuracy — 20%
- Style and concision — 15%
04 · Judgment
Response B is stronger because it satisfies every explicit constraint. Response A may read naturally, but it fails two objective requirements; fluency cannot compensate for instruction-following failures.
05 · Improved answer / next step
Preserve B’s compliance, then tighten any sentence that does not directly support the requested explanation.